Comprehensive Guide to Comfrey
The Complete Guide to Comfrey: Nature's Regenerative Powerhouse
In the intricate tapestry of regenerative agriculture, few plants command the respect and fascination that comfrey does. This remarkable herb—often overlooked amidst more fashionable cover crops—quietly performs soil magic beneath our feet while supporting a cascade of ecological benefits above ground.
As someone who's spent years learning about healing herbs and their agricultural applications, I've come to view comfrey not merely as a plant, but as a living bridge between soil health and plant vitality. Today, I'd like to introduce you to the diverse members of the comfrey family and reveal why this "living mulch" deserves a prominent place in your garden, farm, or food forest.
A Brief History: Comfrey Through the Ages
Before we dive into species and applications, let's appreciate comfrey's remarkable historical journey. As Lawrence D. Hills—widely regarded as the foremost modern authority on comfrey—documented in his groundbreaking work Comfrey: Past, Present and Future, this plant has been a faithful companion to human civilization for millennia.
The name "comfrey" derives from the Latin conferva, meaning "to grow together" or "to heal"—a testament to its ancient reputation as a wound-healing herb. Archaeological evidence suggests comfrey was cultivated as early as 400 BCE. Greek physician Dioscorides documented its use for healing broken bones in the 1st century CE, while medieval European monasteries cultivated it as an essential medicinal herb.
The 18th century saw Henry Doubleday—an English Quaker and naturalist—become fascinated with comfrey's potential to address hunger and nutritional deficiencies. This eventually led to the establishment of the Henry Doubleday Research Association (now Garden Organic), which continues research on comfrey to this day. It was through this organization that Lawrence Hills later developed his famous "Bocking" comfrey cultivars in the mid-20th century, named after the town in Essex where they were bred.
Understanding the Symphytum Genus: A Family of Healers
The Symphytum genus includes approximately 35 recognized species, primarily native to Europe and Asia, with some extending into North Africa. While they all share characteristic deep-rooting, nutrient-accumulating, and medicinal properties, they vary significantly in size, flower color, growth habits, and practical applications.
Let's meet the most notable members of this remarkable botanical family:
1. Symphytum officinale — Common Comfrey
Show Image
Native to Europe and Asia, Common Comfrey presents with purple, pink, or white flowers and grows in a clumping perennial habit. Historically known as "Knitbone," it earned its reputation in traditional medicine for accelerating the healing of bone fractures and tissue damage.
This species excels in medicinal applications and dynamic nutrient accumulation, but be mindful—it can self-seed aggressively under certain conditions.
2. Symphytum × uplandicum — Russian Comfrey (Hybrid)
The workhorse of regenerative agriculture, Russian Comfrey is a hybrid cross between S. officinale and S. asperum. Its blue-violet (occasionally pink) flowers top larger, faster-growing plants than Common Comfrey. The true game-changer here is that as a sterile hybrid, Russian Comfrey doesn't self-seed, making it far easier to manage.
The most celebrated strain, Bocking 14, was specifically bred for high potassium content and non-invasive properties, making it the preferred choice for biomass production, mulch, compost, and permaculture systems.
3. Symphytum asperum — Rough Comfrey
Native to the Caucasus, Iran, and Central Asia, Rough Comfrey sports blue or purple flowers on taller, coarser frames than Common Comfrey. The distinguishing feature is the bristly hairs covering its leaves. While not commonly cultivated on its own, it contributed the vigor and size to create the hybrid Russian Comfrey.
4. Symphytum tuberosum — Tuberous Comfrey
This European and Western Asian native presents delicate pale yellow flowers on a shorter, more compact frame. Unlike its cousins, Tuberous Comfrey spreads through underground tubers rather than seeds or runners, making it perfect as a groundcover in shade-tolerant areas and forest gardens.
5. Symphytum caucasicum — Caucasian Comfrey
With its bright blue flowers and low-growing, creeping habit, Caucasian Comfrey (native to the Caucasus, Turkey, and Iran) excels at erosion control and beautifying pollinator-friendly gardens.
6. Symphytum grandiflorum — Large-Flowered Comfrey
Sporting yellow or cream flowers on a lower-growing frame, Large-Flowered Comfrey spreads through rhizomes, making it ideal for ornamental purposes, erosion control, and companion planting. Many permaculture designers value it as a groundcover.
7. Symphytum ibericum — Iberian Comfrey
This short, creeping groundcover from the Caucasus and Turkey produces pink, purple, or blue flowers. Its exceptional shade tolerance makes it valuable for woodland plantings and understory development in food forests.
8-10. Lesser-Known Varieties
The comfrey family also includes several less common but still valuable species:
Symphytum orientale (Oriental Comfrey) — Creamy white flowers and dense foliage make it attractive in ornamental gardens and wildlife habitats
Symphytum bohemicum (Bohemian Comfrey) — A tall, vigorous species with blue to violet flowers, excellent for wild meadows
Symphytum tauricum (Crimean Comfrey) — A small, compact, drought-tolerant species that thrives in rocky landscapes
Choosing the Right Comfrey for Your Needs
When selecting comfrey for your garden or farm, consider your specific goals:
Comfrey's Superpower: Biofield Energy and Soil Healing
What sets comfrey apart from many other beneficial plants is its remarkable capacity to function as both a physical and energetic healing force in the soil. Just as it earned the name "Knitbone" for helping human fractures mend, comfrey knits together damaged soil systems through multiple mechanisms:
The Medicine-Maker's Secret
Comfrey's high allantoin content—the same compound that accelerates wound healing in humans—stimulates cell regeneration in soil organisms. This plant literally transfers its medicinal properties from human systems to soil systems:
It regenerates compacted and depleted soils by pulling up deep minerals
Encourages microbial renewal through rich biomass contributions
Balances microbial populations, supporting fungal-dominant soil environments where trees and perennials thrive
The Deep-Root Networker
Imagine a plant whose roots can penetrate 6+ feet into the subsoil, creating an energetic bridge between underground minerals and surface-dwelling organisms. Comfrey's extensive taproot doesn't just mine nutrients—it establishes vital communication pathways between soil layers that would otherwise remain disconnected.
Practical Applications: Putting Comfrey to Work
Harvesting with the Moon
For maximum effectiveness, consider lunar timing when working with comfrey:
Waning Moon: Harvest during this phase to enhance root-strengthening effects and decomposition synergy
Early Morning: Gather leaves when allantoin and essential minerals are at their peak, before heat reduces potency
Processing Methods for Maximum Benefit
Fermentation: Liquid Gold for Gardens
Comfrey Fermented Plant Extract (FPE) releases potassium and phosphorus rapidly into the soil. When combined with nettle, it creates a balanced nitrogen-potassium fertilizer that plants readily absorb.
Chop-and-Drop: Instant Soil Feeding
Perhaps the simplest method: freshly cut comfrey decomposes within weeks, feeding worms and soil fungi directly where it's needed.
Comfrey Tea: Potassium Powerhouse
By steeping leaves in water for 2-3 weeks, you create a potent (albeit fragrant!) liquid fertilizer particularly beneficial for fruiting and flowering crops.
Advanced Applications: Beyond Basic Garden Use
1. Climate Resilience and Carbon Sequestration
Comfrey's rapid biomass accumulation means it absorbs CO₂ faster than most plants. When used as green manure, it effectively sequesters carbon into the soil while its deep roots access moisture long after other plants have succumbed to drought.
2. Livestock Fodder: The Forgotten Superfood
Building on Lawrence Hills' extensive research in Comfrey: Fodder, Food & Remedy, we find compelling evidence for comfrey's exceptional value as animal feed. With protein content that can reach up to 26% of dry matter (higher than many legumes), comfrey offers a nutritional profile that few plants can match:
Nutritional Analysis (per 100g dry weight)
Protein: 20-26g (comparable to soybeans)
Calcium: 1.5-2.5g (5x higher than alfalfa)
Potassium: 4.5-5.5g (essential for metabolic functions)
Vitamin A: Abundant carotenoids
Vitamin B12: Present in trace amounts (unusual for plant sources)
Trace minerals: Rich in iron, manganese, and copper
This exceptional nutritional density makes comfrey particularly valuable as:
A protein-rich supplement for ruminants (cattle, sheep, goats)
A silage additive that enhances fermentation and preservation
A productivity booster for poultry, potentially increasing egg production by 10-15%
A supplement for rabbits and other small livestock
However, use caution—its pyrrolizidine alkaloid content makes large amounts unsuitable for continuous feeding. Hills' research suggests limiting comfrey to 25-30% of total feed intake, and some modern farmers prefer using only the Bocking 14 variety, which has lower alkaloid levels.
3. Insect and Pollinator Support
Comfrey flowers produce abundant nectar, attracting:
Bees (honeybees, bumblebees, mason bees)
Butterflies and other pollinators
Beneficial hoverflies, which lay eggs that hatch into aphid-eating larvae
4. Disease Prevention
The high silica content in comfrey strengthens plant cell walls, making crops more resistant to:
Powdery mildew
Rust and fungal infections
Bacterial wilts
Human Medicinal Applications: The Original "Miracle Herb"
While our focus has primarily been on comfrey's agricultural benefits, we would be remiss not to address its long history as a medicinal herb—the very purpose for which it was cultivated for centuries before its soil-building properties were fully appreciated.
Andrew Hughes' detailed exploration in Comfrey: Nature's Healing Herb & Health Food highlights the plant's traditional applications, many of which are supported by modern research on its bioactive compounds:
Traditional Applications
Bone healing: The nickname "knitbone" or "boneset" reflects comfrey's traditional use in treating fractures, sprains, and broken bones
Wound healing: Applied topically to accelerate healing of cuts, scrapes, and burns
Anti-inflammatory: Used to soothe arthritis, gout, and other inflammatory conditions
Respiratory support: Traditionally employed for lung ailments and persistent coughs
Active Compounds
The therapeutic properties of comfrey stem from several key compounds:
Allantoin: Stimulates cell proliferation and wound healing
Rosmarinic acid: Provides anti-inflammatory effects
Mucilage: Creates a soothing protective layer on mucous membranes
Pyrrolizidine alkaloids: Controversial compounds with both medicinal and potentially harmful effects
Important Safety Considerations
Modern research has raised important concerns about comfrey's internal use due to its pyrrolizidine alkaloids, which can be hepatotoxic (toxic to the liver). For this reason:
External use only: Most herbalists now recommend comfrey solely for external applications
Limited duration: Even topical treatments should be limited to 4-6 weeks
Avoid on broken skin: Should not be applied to open or infected wounds
Pregnancy/nursing: Not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding
Cultivation Details: Growing Your Own Comfrey
Based on the detailed cultivation techniques outlined in Nancy Shirley's Comfrey Books and Lawrence Hills' practical guides, here are the essentials for successfully establishing comfrey in your garden:
Site Selection & Preparation
Location: Choose a permanent spot—comfrey's deep roots make it difficult to relocate
Soil: While adaptable, comfrey thrives in slightly alkaline (pH 6.5-7.5), well-drained soil
Spacing: Allow 2-3 feet between plants—they will grow quite large over time
Sun exposure: Full sun to partial shade, with more shade tolerance in hot climates
Propagation Methods
Root cuttings (most reliable): 2-6 inch segments planted horizontally 2-3 inches deep
Crown divisions: Separate mature plants in early spring or fall
Seeds: Viable only for fertile varieties (not Russian comfrey), with spotty germination
Maintenance
Watering: Regular moisture during establishment; drought-tolerant once established
Harvesting: Begin light harvests after the first year, cutting leaves 2-3 inches above the crown
Containment: Monitor spread for self-seeding varieties; consider planting in sunken barriers
Winter care: Cut back in late fall; mulch in very cold regions (though rarely necessary)
Final Thoughts: The Living Legacy of Comfrey
Whether you're a backyard gardener, a permaculture designer, or a regenerative farmer, at least one comfrey species deserves space in your growing system. For most practical purposes, Russian Comfrey (Symphytum × uplandicum), particularly the Bocking 14 variety, offers the best combination of benefits with minimal management challenges.
Remember that comfrey is more than just a "super plant"—it's a living bridge between soil health and plant vitality, a bioelectrical connector that enhances quantum-level microbial communication in soils, and a resilient ally in creating regenerative growing systems.
As we face increasing climate uncertainty and soil degradation, these ancient healing plants offer surprisingly modern solutions to some of our most pressing agricultural challenges. As Lawrence Hills prophetically noted decades ago, comfrey may well be one of our most valuable allies in building a sustainable agricultural future.
Recommended Reading
For those interested in diving deeper into comfrey research and applications, these foundational works provide exceptional insights:
Comfrey: Past, Present and Future – Lawrence D. Hills – The definitive work on comfrey from the 20th century's leading authority
Comfrey: Fodder, Food & Remedy – Lawrence D. Hills – Focused exploration of comfrey's use beyond gardening
Comfrey Books: Volumes 1 & 2 – Nancy Shirley – Comprehensive coverage of botany, history, and cultivation techniques
Comfrey: Nature's Healing Herb & Health Food – Andrew Hughes – In-depth look at medicinal applications and nutritional value
Comfrey: Symphytum—A Multi-Purpose Herb – Philip Clarke – Practical guide to integrating comfrey into sustainable systems
Have you grown comfrey in your garden or on your farm? Which variety do you prefer, and what benefits have you observed? Share your experiences in the comments below!
Advanced Fermentation Techniques: Using Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) with Comfrey Extracts
Beyond traditional Fermented Plant Juice (FPJ), integrating Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) cultures with Comfrey extracts enhances the bioavailability of nutrients, promotes microbial diversity, and strengthens plant and soil resilience. This technique combines the potency of comfrey’s nutrient-dense profile with the microbial power of LAB, creating a multi-functional biofertilizer and soil amendment.
1. Why Use Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) with Comfrey?
Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) are facultative anaerobes, meaning they can function both aerobically and anaerobically, making them excellent for:
Decomposing organic matter faster than standard FPJ.
Suppressing pathogens while promoting beneficial soil microbes.
Enhancing fermentation stability, preventing spoilage.
Improving nutrient absorption in plants via bioactive compounds.
Supporting plant immune function, reducing fungal diseases and root rot.
How LAB Interacts with Comfrey Extracts:
LAB breaks down comfrey’s complex plant compounds, releasing soluble potassium, calcium, phosphorus, and silica into bioavailable forms.
Lactic acid prevents spoilage, ensuring the extract remains stable for long-term storage.
Boosts indigenous soil microorganisms (IMO) when applied as a foliar spray or soil drench.
Enhances root-zone microbial communication, improving mycorrhizal fungi interactions.
2. Fermentation Process: How to Make a Comfrey + LAB Extract
Ingredients & Materials:
Fresh Comfrey leaves & stems (1 kg)
Lactic Acid Bacteria Serum (LAB) (~500 mL)
Raw Cane Sugar, Molasses, or Brown Sugar (1 kg)
Non-chlorinated Water (5-10 L)
Glass or plastic fermenting container (bucket or jar with a breathable cover)
Step-by-Step Instructions:
Phase 1: Prepare the LAB Culture
Collect LAB
Wash uncooked rice (1 cup) in non-chlorinated water.
Let the rice water sit for 1-2 days at room temperature until it develops a slightly sour smell.
Feed the LAB
Mix the rice water with milk (10:1 ratio).
Let sit for 5-7 days until the milk separates into curds and whey.
Strain and collect the yellowish liquid (LAB serum).
Store LAB
Add equal parts molasses to stabilize the LAB culture.
Store in the fridge or a cool place.
Phase 2: Fermenting the Comfrey Extract with LAB
Chop fresh comfrey leaves and stems into small pieces for faster fermentation.
Mix comfrey with sugar (1:1 ratio) to draw out plant juices.
Mash the mixture to release natural plant juices.
Add LAB serum (about 500 mL per 10 L water).
Cover loosely to allow gas exchange but prevent contamination.
Ferment for 7-14 days, stirring daily to release gases.
Strain and store in a cool place.
3. How to Use LAB + Comfrey Extract in Holistic Farming
1. Foliar Spray (for Growth Acceleration & Disease Resistance)
Dilution Ratio: 1:500 (2 mL LAB-Comfrey extract per liter of water)
Best Application Time: Early morning or late afternoon to avoid leaf burn.
Effects:
Encourages stronger leaf growth.
Reduces fungal infections (powdery mildew, root rot, downy mildew).
Enhances stomatal efficiency for increased CO₂ absorption.
2. Soil Drench (For Fungal-Dominant Soil and Root Strength)
Dilution Ratio: 1:300 (3-5 mL per liter of water)
Best Application Time: Before planting or once every two weeks in established plants.
Effects:
Feeds mycorrhizal fungi and beneficial bacteria.
Enhances potassium, phosphorus, and calcium uptake.
Prepares soil for better microbial networking, improving soil structure.
3. Compost Activator (Speed Up Decomposition)
Dilution Ratio: 1:100 (10 mL per liter of water)
Application: Pour over compost piles to accelerate decomposition.
Effects:
Increases heat in the compost, reducing bad odors.
Breaks down plant materials faster, creating high-fungal humus.
Boosts protozoa and fungal balance, leading to more stable organic matter.
4. Seed Soak (Boost Germination & Root Development)
Dilution Ratio: 1:1000 (1 mL per liter of water)
Soaking Time: 2-6 hours before planting.
Effects:
Accelerates seed germination by breaking dormancy.
Improves resistance to early-stage fungal infections.
Enhances root exudation, improving microbial colonization at the rhizosphere.
4. Additional Enhancements: Making LAB + Comfrey Supercharged
Enhancement 1: Add Biochar for Extended Soil Benefits
LAB-comfrey fermented with biochar enhances:
Long-term microbial stability in soil.
Higher water retention in drought-prone regions.
Microbial habitat protection, extending the LAB effect.
Enhancement 2: Add Indigenous Microorganisms (IMO)
Mixing IMO (wild soil fungi) into LAB + Comfrey Extract creates a full-spectrum soil inoculant.
Best for forest farming, fungal-dominant soil systems, and restoring degraded lands.
Enhancement 3: Use Electro-Agriculture Techniques
Using Schumann resonance (7.83 Hz sound frequencies) while fermenting enhances quantum microbial communication, optimizing soil bioelectrics.
5. Why This Fermentation Technique is Superior to Traditional FPJ
6. Conclusion: Why LAB + Comfrey Extract is a Game-Changer
This next-generation fermentation approach unlocks new levels of soil and plant health by combining comfrey’s deep-mined nutrients with LAB’s microbial power.
Benefits of Using LAB + Comfrey Extract:
Faster nutrient absorption for plants.
Suppresses plant and soil pathogens (fungal & bacterial).
Creates bioavailable potassium, phosphorus, and silica for plant immunity.
Increases compost efficiency, reducing decomposition time.
Improves soil texture, boosting drought resilience.
Who is the farmer behind this Substack? A fellow natural farmer I see. :)